Tuesday, October 14, 2025

The Complexity Of Ranking NFL Quarterbacks

Image

The Pittsburgh Steelers have made a strong start to the 2025 NFL season, sitting atop the AFC North with a 3-1 record. Veteran quarterback Aaron Rodgers has been a key factor in their success, with efficient and controlled play helping to steady the team. According to Pro Football Focus (PFF), Rodgers has completed 68. 5% of his passes for 786 yards, throwing eight touchdowns with just three interceptions, and has a quarterback rating of 102. 6 (source: www. marca. com → en → nfl → pittsburgh-steelers → 2025 → 10 → 12 → 68eb0ab5268e3ee67f8b457f. html). Despite his impressive stats, PFF recently ranked Rodgers as the worst starting quarterback in the NFL, citing his failure to push the ball downfield and create "explosive" plays. However, analysts and fans have widely criticized this ranking, with Colin Cowherd of Fox Sports questioning how Rodgers could be placed beneath less accomplished quarterbacks like Jake Browning or Cooper Rush. Starkey emphasized that Rodgers' strength lies in his decision-making and ability to deliver in key moments, highlighting his stellar Week 1 performance against the Jets, where he went 22-of-30 passing ← →

The art of ranking NFL quarterbacks is a contentious one, often sparking heated debates among analysts, fans, and coaches. So, metrics such as passer rating, completion percentage, and yards per attempt provide a quantitative framework for evaluating quarterback performance. However, these statistics can be misleading, failing to account for intangible factors like leadership, clutch gene, and situational awareness.

For instance, a quarterback may excel in a system that emphasizes short, high-percentage passes, but struggle in a more aggressive, downfield-oriented ---se. Pro Football Focus, a prominent source for advanced NFL analytics, has developed a comprehensive grading system that seeks to capture the nuances of quarterback play.

Their rankings are based on a detailed evaluation of every snap, taking into account factors such as decision-making, accuracy, and athleticism.

However, even PFF's system is not immune to criticism, with some arguing that it prioritizes certain skills over others or fails to adequately account for team context. As a result, quarterback rankings often become a source of controversy, with different outlets and analysts producing vastly different assessments of the same players.

The subjectivity inherent in quarterback rankings is further complicated by the ever-changing NFL landscape.

A quarterback's performance can fluctuate significantly from year to year, influenced by factors such ← →

• • • •

T he Pittsburgh Steelers have raced to a 3-1 start in the 2025 NFL season, sitting atop the AFC North.
Other references and insights: Visit website

No comments:

Post a Comment